Private Healthcare Comparison
Compare private healthcare options in the UK. Understand the differences between private health insurance, health cash plans, self-pay, and NHS pay-and-go options.
Last updated: 31 March 2026
What Are Your Private Healthcare Options?
"Private healthcare" is a broader term than "private health insurance." When people search for a private healthcare comparison, they are often looking to understand all the ways to access private medical treatment in the UK — not just insurance. There are four main routes:
- Private health insurance (PMI) — monthly premiums in exchange for cover when you need treatment. The most comprehensive option for ongoing protection.
- Health cash plans — affordable plans that reimburse everyday healthcare costs like dental, optical, and physiotherapy.
- Self-pay — paying for individual private treatments out of pocket, without insurance.
- NHS pay-and-go — paying for specific NHS services privately to skip waiting lists (where available).
Private Health Insurance vs Self-Pay
The choice between insurance and self-pay depends on how you prefer to manage risk and cost:
When Insurance Makes More Sense
- You want protection against unexpected, expensive treatment (cancer treatment can cost £50,000–£200,000+)
- You anticipate needing multiple consultations or ongoing treatment
- Peace of mind matters — you prefer knowing you are covered without thinking about individual costs
- You are over 50, when the likelihood of needing treatment increases significantly
When Self-Pay Makes More Sense
- You only need a specific, one-off treatment (e.g., a knee MRI at £300–£500)
- You are young and healthy with low risk of needing significant treatment
- You have substantial savings and can absorb unexpected costs
- You want to avoid monthly premiums and only pay when you actually need care
Typical Self-Pay Costs
| Treatment | Typical Self-Pay Cost |
|---|---|
| GP consultation (private) | £50–£100 |
| Specialist consultation | £150–£300 |
| MRI scan | £300–£500 |
| Knee arthroscopy | £3,000–£5,000 |
| Hip replacement | £10,000–£15,000 |
| Cataract surgery (per eye) | £2,500–£3,500 |
| Cancer treatment (typical course) | £50,000–£200,000+ |
Health Cash Plans vs Private Health Insurance
These serve different purposes and many people have both:
| Feature | Health Cash Plan | Private Health Insurance |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost | £5–£30 | £35–£150+ |
| Covers | Dental, optical, physio, routine care | Specialist treatment, surgery, hospital stays |
| Pre-existing conditions | Usually covered | Usually excluded |
| Age-related pricing | No | Yes |
| Claims process | Submit receipts for cashback | Provider pays hospital directly |
| Best for | Routine healthcare costs | Serious/acute medical treatment |
For a detailed guide, see our health cash plan page and our guide to cash plans vs private health insurance.
NHS Pay-and-Go Options
A lesser-known option is paying for specific NHS services privately. Some NHS trusts offer "fast-track" or "pay-and-go" services for diagnostics and minor procedures. This can be cheaper than going fully private because NHS facilities have lower overheads than private hospitals. However, availability varies significantly by region and hospital trust.
Examples include paying for a faster MRI scan at an NHS hospital or opting for a private room during an NHS admission. These options are not widely advertised, so ask your GP or the hospital directly.
Comparing All Options Side by Side
| Option | Cost | Best For | Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Private health insurance | £35–£150+/mo | Comprehensive ongoing protection | Monthly premiums; pre-existing conditions excluded |
| Health cash plan | £5–£30/mo | Offsetting routine healthcare costs | Does not cover serious medical treatment |
| Self-pay | Pay per treatment | One-off procedures; young/healthy people | Expensive for major treatment; no cost certainty |
| NHS pay-and-go | Varies | Faster NHS diagnostics | Limited availability; not all treatments offered |
Our Recommendation
For most UK adults, the optimal approach is:
- Private health insurance for protection against serious conditions — the financial and access benefits outweigh the monthly cost, especially if you choose a smart combination of excess and cover level.
- A health cash plan alongside it for everyday costs — at £7–£15/month, it typically pays for itself through dental and optical claims alone.
- Self-pay for minor, predictable treatments where the cost is known and manageable.
Start by comparing private health insurance to find the right core policy, then consider adding a health cash plan for everyday cover.